Ask Arthur: Over-ear or on-ear headphones?

Q: Which is better? Over-ear or on-ear headphones?

A: The choice between on-ear and over-ear designs can be confusing, but it really comes down to personal preference, as both have pros and cons.

On-ear headphones, also known as supra-aural headphones, rest on top of the ears. They are smaller and resemble the shape of your ear. Key considerations include:

• Comfort and sweat: On-ear headphones are generally comfortable and cause less sweating compared to over-ear models. 
• Sound leakage: on-ear headphones allow some sound from the surrounding environment to enter and exit.
• Lighter and Less Pressure: They are lighter than over-ear models, resulting in less pressure on the top band that rests on your head. That can make for a more comfortable listening experience.
• Sound quality and comfort: On-ear headphones come in various quality levels, but higher-end models deliver great sound quality and comfort. 

Over-ear headphones, or “circumaural headphones” if you want to be too smart, fully encompass the ears within the ear cups. Key considerations include:

• Sound isolation: Over-ear headphones are best for blocking external sounds and providing noise isolation, creating a more intimate environment between you and your music.
• Comfort and sweat: With their larger cups and cushioning, over-ear headphones offer comfortable wear, but can cause some sweating due to minimal air circulation.
• Bulky design: Over-ear headphones are bulkier and may not be ideal if you’re looking to save space.
• Extended use vs Sound quality: While heavier and potentially causing fatigue during extended wear, over-ear headphones deliver superior sound quality and are preferred by audiophiles, studio professionals, and gamers who want immersive audio experience.

Ultimately, it comes down to what suits your individual preferences.