When the
new LG Velvet phone was launched via Facebook Live last week, it was hyped as “the
best phone out there” by a pair of influencers roped in to wow the phone’s
target audience. And for the audience, namely the masses who would flock to
Facebook for a product launch, that may well be true.
The key
selling point of the Velvet is that it is the lowest cost 5G phone to arrive in
South Africa, coming in at R13,499. That is marginally below the previous winner
in this category, which also happens to be a 5G device: the LG V50 ThinQ.
It arrived
in March at R13,599. However, at the time, no 5G network was switched on for
mobile phones. Only Rain had rolled out 5G, but that was only for “fixed
wireless”, meaning one had to have a 5G router in the home to pick up the
signal. That is an alternative to fibre-to-the-home broadband rather than to
cellphone wireless broadband.
Much has
changed in the four months since. Thanks to lockdown, the communications
regulator Icasa has issued emergency spectrum to all mobile operators to roll
out 5G on their networks. Vodacom was first, launching at the beginning of May,
followed by MTN at the beginning of July.
When the V50
was launched, its 5G capability was ignored due to the lack of network
capability, but today it slots into a growing range of handsets that can take
advantage of blazing speeds. We tested it shortly after the Vodacom network was
switched on, in an area with poor signal strength – lockdown restrictions kept
us from testing in the heart of Vodacom’s 5G coverage area at the time. The resultant
55Mbps download was the highest yet seen in that area. Already respectable.
Later, with
lockdown easing and when one could expect that the network was more bedded
down, the speeds were regularly over 500Mbps.
Suddenly,
5G is a thing.
Now, it
makes sense to look at the available options, and to compare the phones leading
the need for speed.
LG and
Huawei are at the forefront in South Africa.
The best phone of the lot is no doubt the Huawei P40 Pro (reviewed last week), but it does have the disadvantage of no Google Mobile Services, meaning no Google Play store. Instead, it depends on Huawei Mobile Services and the Huawei AppGallery.
Its camera
capabilities make up for the gap, for those who are, let’s say, image
conscious. With 50 Megapixel wide angle, 40 MP ultra-wide and 12MP telephoto,
it edges out LG’s flagship, the V60 ThinQ. The latter comes in at an eye-watering
64MP standard lens, but coupled with only a 13MP ultrawide and a 0.3MP depth
lens.
Of course,
it is the software that really dictates image quality, but LG has not been
getting the best reviews in this department lately. We’ll give our impressions
when we get our hands on the new devices, and in due course will explore the
P40 Pro camera in more detail.
The price
of 5G on flagship phones may well keep the mass market away. The Huawei P40 Pro
ranges between R17,999 and R24,999, depending on outlet, while the LG V60 starts
at R20,999.
In that
context, the Velvet suddenly comes into its own. If camera is not key, and
streaming speeds are important – the phone can also be used as a portable
hotspot – it truly shines.
Despite
being the lowest cost 5G phone in South Africa right now, it also happens to
have two features that differentiate it. It is the first of the 5G phones available
here that uses Qualcomm’s new Snapdragon 765G chipset. That doesn’t sound more
powerful than the Snapdragon 865 used in the V60, but it is in fact the first
mobile phone chipset from Qualcomm that builds the 5G modem into the processor.
The more powerful chips are required to be installed alongside a separate 5G
modem, adding to the bulk and reducing efficiency.
This brings
us to the Velvet’s second differentiator: it’s size and weight. Thanks to the
combination in the 765G chip, it weighs only 180g, compared to the V60’s 213g
and the P40 Pro’s 208g. The latter runs on Huawei’s own Kirin 990 5G chip,
which gives it powerful artificial intelligence capabilities – also a story for
another day.
One may not
be able to tell with a 33g difference, but a second aspect of its size that
does stand out – or rather recede – is its thickness: a mere 7.9mm, making it
the thinnest 5G phone on the local market. The Huawei P40 Pro is just over a
millimeter thicker, at 9mm, while the basic P40 stacks up at 8.5mm, despite
being the lightest of the 5G phones at 175g.
The Velvet
is right up there in terms of screen size, at 6.8-inches, on a par with the
V60, larger than the P40 Pro’s 6.58-inches, and substantially bigger than its
price and weight competitor, the basic P40, which houses only a 6.1-inch
display.
The battery
on the Velvet is not too shabby either, at a hefty 4300mAh, compared to 4200 on
the P40 Pro and 5000 on its big brother, the V60. However, tests by GSMArena
show this overstates its prowess, as it comes in with 15 hours 37 minutes of
video playback time. That’s respectable compared to previous generations of
smartphone, but The V60 leads the way at 23:31, the P40 Pro offers up 18:11,
and the P40 18:37.
At a price
ranging from R14,499 to R18,699, this makes the basic P40 the best value for
money in the 5G streaming department, while the Velvet leads the price war in
terms of look and feel, as well as that vital element of Google Play services.
- Arthur Goldstuck is founder of World Wide Worx and editor-in-chief of
Gadget.co.za. Follow him on Twitter and Instagram on @art2gee
